Skip to main content
This site is in Beta Stage. Check data with an alternate resource before taking any action.

Planning Commission

Public meeting record

Planning Commission Regular Meeting Meeting

Thursday, August 17, 2023 · Time unknowncompletedCity Council Chambers, City Hall, 160 Zoll Street, Harbor Springs, MI 49740

Detailed briefing

This summary was prepared with AI assistance from unofficial meeting records and may contain errors. It is not official minutes — use the agenda, minutes, and video links above to verify.

Planning Commission Regular Meeting — August 17, 2023 ATTENDEES: Roll call recorded Vanessa Warren, Emily DeBakey, Bob Thoma, Bill Holder, Mark Boudet, Nancy Rondeau, and later Rick Bartinski; a quorum was declared. • The commission approved the July 20 meeting minutes. • After opening and closing a public hearing, the commission approved a special land use request for a two-story accessory structure with guest quarters at 1 Beach Drive. Staff said the guest-quarters use is allowed by right in the applicable zoning district, but Planning Commission approval was needed because the accessory structure is two stories. The recorded roll-call responses were all yes. • Property owner Rob Sears said the project is a new home and detached garage on the corner of Beach Drive and Pennsylvania, with the accessory structure near Pennsylvania and Zoll streets. He said the team plans to cut back a hedge near the Pennsylvania/Zoll corner to improve visibility, seek a building permit the following week, break ground in the fall, and target a move-in the next summer. • Staff said special land use approval is valid for one year to obtain permits and begin physical activity; an additional one-year extension may be requested. The applicant said the project is not expected to need more than the initial year to start. Commissioners also discussed having the main home substantially underway before the accessory building progresses, although the applicant said both would be built at the same time. • Anna McGlashan of Tip of the Mitt Watershed Council presented stormwater-management options. She described increased runoff volume and rate from impervious surfaces and identified nature-based approaches such as shoreline vegetation, rain gardens, vegetated swales, permeable surfaces, tree-canopy preservation, and pollutant prevention. She offered the Watershed Council as a resource for zoning language and project consultation. • Commissioners discussed possible future code review involving greenbelts, impervious-surface limits, permeable paving, grading plans, drainage impacts on neighboring properties, and tree inventories. No code amendments were adopted. The zoning-code committee said it is preparing to share developing recommendations with the public and remains on track for 2024 approval. Worth watching: • Staff said it will ask the 1 Beach Drive applicant about any intended work on the waterfront/wetland side of the road; staff said such work may need separate zoning approval. • Stormwater-related standards may be considered as the zoning code is rewritten, but no specific revisions or timetable were adopted. • The commission raised concerns about runoff and erosion controls near the project area and noted that outside permits may be required for wetland or water-related work. Upcoming: A rain-garden project/workshop at the Ottawa Stadium parking lot was announced for August 25. Why it matters: The meeting paired approval of a specific residential project with a broader discussion of how future zoning and site review could better address drainage, water quality, and development impacts.

Agenda items

  • 5A · Special Land Use Request - 1 Beach Dr. - Two Story Accessory Structurediscussed
  • 5B · Presentation - Storm Water Solutions - Anna McGlashendiscussed

Public follow-ups

No open public follow-ups are linked to this meeting yet.

Related issues

Stay updated on Planning Commission

Meeting details are public for everyone. Create a free citizen account to watch this board and keep follow-ups in your account — registration is optional for reading this page.

Watching requires a free citizen account — use Watch to register.