City Manager Interviews on YOU TUBE : Click here –  https://www.youtube.com/watch?app=desktop&v=YQxjQxxU9os

Hear for yourself – thank you to all involved. 

If you happen to know people from these communities, perhaps reach out and see what they think

A Snapshot of the City Manager Candidates

Yesterday, the Harbor Springs City Council interviewed four candidates for the City Manager position. The interviews were recorded, and the recordings are expected to be released tomorrow for public viewing.

Since candidate resumes were not made available to the public in advance of the interviews, we have done our best to summarize each candidate’s background and experience based on the information shared during the interviews. Below is a brief summary of each candidate, along with several notable quotes from their responses.

There will be an important conversation, and potentially a vote, on the next City Manager at the City Council meeting on Monday, making it especially helpful for residents to become familiar with the candidates ahead of that discussion.

Residents who would like to listen to the full interviews can do so once the City releases the recordings.

Kip Belcher

Background

  • Career law enforcement officer with the Michigan State Police
  • Previously worked for the Michigan Department of Corrections
  • Spent much of his career in plainclothes investigations focused on felony drug cases
  • Later supervised multi-agency drug task forces covering 19 counties in Northern Michigan

Selected Quotes

On leadership style

‘I don’t believe that sitting behind a desk and punching keyboard keys is representative of the best leadership.’

On Harbor Springs growth and zoning

‘You’re about tapped out right now on the number of city residents… but as far as housing goes, you don’t have a whole lot of vacant areas right now. And the zoning as it exists right now, precludes some building activity from taking place.’

On planning and city priorities

‘If those priorities don’t match…with the different discussions that go on and policies and ordinances that are passed, then it’s all upside down.’


Chris Kukulski

Background

  • Career city manager, recently in Billings, Bozeman, and Kalispell, Montana
  • Originally from Michigan, born in Caro and raised in North Branch
  • Previously served as city managers or administrators in Kalispell, Bozeman, and Billings, Montana
  • Experience managing large municipal budgets and infrastructure systems

Selected Quotes

On his connection to Michigan

‘I am not from Montana. I am from Michigan. I am a Michigander… my dream honestly, once I became a city manager, was to be on Lake Michigan in Harbor Springs or Petoskey.’

On infrastructure stewardship

‘I think Harbor Springs citizens probably own upwards of a quarter billion dollars worth of assets. 18 miles of streets. You got 18 miles of water mains underneath those streets. A harbor, the electric utility, 75 miles of electric lines. All of those assets have a value. And in my opinion, it is a responsibility of ours to make sure that we’re properly taking care of those assets.’

On community trust

‘Everything we do is based on trust. And so, the more transparent we are, the more accessible we are in what we do and the decisions we make and how we invest their tax dollars..the higher level that confidence is. And then frankly, it allows us to do our job so much better. Because when there’s not trust, everything slows down.’

On long-term leadership

‘I am more interested in a multi generational impact that we have than what might be the headline in the Petoskey paper or in our local paper here.’


Scott Czasak

Background

  • Current City Manager in Caro, Michigan
  • Former staffer in the U.S. House of Representatives and the Michigan House of Representatives
  • Holds a Master’s Degree in Public Administration

Selected Quotes

On learning a community

‘The true way of learning a community is being in it… the people aren’t a plan. They’re people that have individual day-to-day responsibilities, day-to-day concerns.’

On local government realities

‘Everyone wants stuff, but no one wants to pay for it.’

On leadership

‘Leadership is not always about being in front. Sometimes it’s about being behind.’

On stewardship

‘I’m a temporary cog in the wheel. Just like all of you are, all the staff is. The cities we work for, this city, the city I work for, they were here long before us. They’ll be here long after us. We’re a temporary steward…to do the best we can to make things better.’


Gregory Elliott

Background

  • Born and raised in Manistee, Michigan
  • Holds degrees in Business Administration and Public Administration
  • Worked 10 years in Pittsfield Township, overseeing planning, water, and sewer operations
  • Later worked as a real estate and development attorney and planning consultant
  • Served about five years as City Administrator in Adrian, Michigan, and current Manager of Chocolay Township, Michigan

Selected Quotes

On familiarity with Harbor Springs

‘I do know Harbor Springs… I’ve been there a lot over the years and I’m familiar with the city.’

On public policy

‘The lesson is don’t get out ahead of your constituency… if you can’t sell it to the people then you shouldn’t be pursuing it.’

On city finances

‘You have to be careful with your funds and make sure you’re good stewards of the people’s money.’

On leadership style

‘I like to have a very collaborative style with staff… the best ideas come out of everybody hanging out and talking together.’

What Happens Next

The full interview recordings are above allowing residents to listen to the full discussions with each candidate.

Information regarding the next steps in the selection process has not yet been made public. However, there is an agenda item related to the City Manager position at Monday’s City Council meeting.

In many municipal searches, the process can include additional steps such as independent reference checks, opportunities for department heads or city staff to meet with finalists, or community meet-and-greet sessions. It is not yet clear whether any of these steps will be part of the Harbor Springs process.

Given the importance of the role, many residents may want to take time to review the interviews and learn more about the candidates as the process moves forward. Please watch for City Hall postings of the interviews. Or reach out to City Council members to express your views.

 

Here is ours: 

Monday, March 9, 2026
Harbor Springs City Council
City of Harbor Springs
160 Zol St
Harbor Springs, Ml 49740
Dear Mayor, City Council Members, and Interim City Manager,

The City Manager search is one of the most consequential decisions this Council will make, and we
appreciate the care being put into it.

One addition would make the outcome stronger: a dedicated public input session at a City Council meeting
on Zoom, structured around focused questions and open to discussion.

Here is the practical case. What residents say publicly about this role becomes the standard they will use to
evaluate it. Capturing that now gives the Council a clear, community-sourced performance baseline, and
lets Harbor Springs’ residents, who have deep collective experience across business, government, and
civic life inform the criteria before a decision is made, not after.

We suggest three questions to anchor the session:
1. What should the City Manager’s top priorities be for Harbor Springs over the next three years?
2. What experience or background should the City Manager have to succeed in this specific
community?
3. What will tell us, two years from now, that we made a great hire?

That is not just good process. It is useful intelligence that makes a great hiring decision easier to reach,
easier to defend, and easier to sustain.

Thank you for considering it. We are happy to help structure the agenda if useful. We’d like this letter
placed in the March 16th packet.
Karin Offield, WTT for
We Love Harbor Springs
Box 2, Harbor Springs, Michigan 49740
W
WE LOVE HARBOR SPRINGS

What are your questions?

We are acknowledging that City Council members are volunteers who have taken on a serious responsibility to lead the community. Shared responsibility emphasizes that citizens asking questions or doing research are holding themselves to the same standard of effort they expect from City Council.

It suggests a spirit of mutual accountability never criticism.   For those of you making comments on Facebook in plain terms, we are saying, we recognize Council members are volunteering and the job is difficult – but the community is also putting in time and effort. Therefore it is reasonable to expect thoughtful work and engagement from everyone involved.

Two years ago many community conversations were framed as “yes” or “no.”   Those moments can happen in small towns when important decisions are being discussed.

But today the goal is different.  We are reaching out to the entire community — yeses, nos, maybes, and everyone in between — and inviting each of you to help think about the qualities and leadership Harbor Springs should look for in its next City Manager.

This is an opportunity for all of us to share ideas about the future of our town.

MANAGING A SEASONAL COMMUNITY
Harbor Springs operates within the unique dynamics of a seasonal community. Second-home ownership significantly increases the population during parts of the year, placing additional demands on infrastructure, public services, housing, and city operations. Tourism that is growing adds another layer to these pressures.
Balancing these demands while preserving Harbor Springs’ historic character and small-town identity requires thoughtful planning and steady communication. Successful leadership in a community like ours often depends on maintaining strong relationships among year-round residents, seasonal property owners, local businesses, and city staff. Also the Chamber of Commerce and the Downtown Development Authority (DDA).
Understanding these dynamics can help guide decisions that support both the vitality of the community and the long-term well-being of the people who live and work here.
QUESTIONS
• What strategies would you use to manage the challenges that come with leading a seasonal resort community like Harbor Springs?
• In order to understand the community’s needs, it is often important to spend time listening and learning before making major decisions. During your first six months, how would you plan to familiarize yourself with Harbor Springs’ character, priorities, and long-standing community values?
• Harbor Springs faces ongoing infrastructure needs, including roads, sidewalks, and electrical system upgrades. How do you approach long-term capital planning so the city can address these needs for our residents first and tourists without creating unsustainable financial pressure?
• How would you ensure that community members feel heard and respected throughout the decision-making process, particularly when there are differing viewpoints within the community?
• Seasonal communities often experience large swings in service demand throughout the year. How would you plan staffing, budgeting, and municipal services to meet peak seasonal needs while remaining responsible to year-round taxpayers?
What questions would you ask someone applying to be Harbor Springs’ next City Manager?
ADMINISTRATIVE LEADERSHIP AND CUSTOMER SERVICE
The City Manager serves as the chief administrative officer of the city, overseeing municipal staff, implementing policies established by the City Council, managing budgets, and ensuring that city departments operate effectively and efficiently.
The City Manager’s office plays a central role in coordinating the work of city departments such as the Department of Public Works, supporting staff, and helping translate council priorities into practical action. Maintaining public trust through transparent and respectful communication with residents is also fundamental to the position.
Municipal governments across the country are also experiencing challenges with staff recruitment and retention, making strong administrative leadership increasingly important.
QUESTIONS
• What leadership approach would you take when working with the City Council, municipal staff, and members of the community?
• How do you define a successful working relationship between a City Manager and the City Council, particularly when council members may have differing priorities or expectations?
• Communication and customer service play an important role in building public trust. How would you approach communication with residents and staff, particularly when addressing difficult issues or concerns?
• Tell us about a decision you made as a municipal leader that did not work out as intended. What did you learn from that experience, and how did it change the way you lead or make decisions today?
MUNICIPAL ELECTRIC UTILITY OVERSIGHT 
One of Harbor Springs’ most distinctive responsibilities is operating its own municipal electric utility, which serves approximately 3,700 customers. Managing a system of this kind requires attention to power purchasing, infrastructure reliability, rate structures, and long-term capital planning.  Municipal electric utilities are specialized operations. Effective management typically relies on experienced technical staff supported by strong executive oversight and informed policy direction from city leadership.  As Harbor Springs looks toward the future, thoughtful leadership and planning will be important to ensure the reliability, resilience, and financial stability of this essential public service.

QUESTIONS

  • What experience do you have working with municipal utilities, particularly electric systems?
  • If you have not previously managed a municipal electric utility, how would you prepare to oversee one responsibly and develop the expertise needed to support staff and guide policy decisions?
  • Communication during power outages remains an important concern for many residents. What steps would you take to improve communication systems during outages so residents receive timely and accurate information?
  • Communities across the Great Lakes region are experiencing more severe weather events. How do you approach emergency preparedness and infrastructure resilience so that residents are protected and critical services remain reliable?

BALANCING GROWTH AND COMMUNITY CHARACTER TO PRESERVE AND PROTECT

Residents of Harbor Springs frequently express the importance of preserving the town’s historic character while supporting thoughtful economic vitality. Achieving that balance requires careful decision-making, clear planning, and a long-term perspective.  Harbor Springs has long valued its small scale, historic neighborhoods, and waterfront setting. Growth and change inevitably occur, but they must be guided in ways that respect the qualities that make the community distinctive. The next City Manager will play an important role in helping the city and its residents maintain this balance.  Thoughtful leadership will be needed to ensure that planning decisions, public investments, and development policies reflect both the community’s economic health and its desire to preserve the character that generations have worked to protect.

Questions

  • Harbor Springs recently experience a week-long power outage and fallen trees block roads. What would you recommend city council legislates now to be prepared for potential future disasters?
  • How would you approach balancing development pressures with the preservation of Harbor Springs’ character, scale, and historic identity?
  • Historically, the Parks Department operated without a full-time director from 1932 until 2022, relying primarily on part-time maintenance staff. In recent years, the parks budget has increased significantly. How would you evaluate the current structure and responsibilities of the Parks Department and its capacity to meet future community needs?
  • Looking ahead, Harbor Springs will continue to face questions about growth, infrastructure, and long-term planning. How would you begin the process of developing a strategic vision for the city, and what steps would you take to ensure that residents, businesses, and seasonal property owners all have an opportunity to contribute to that conversation?
  • What challenges do you believe communities like Harbor Springs are most likely to face in the next decade, and how would you help the city prepare for them?

A  BRIDGE BUILDER HAS STORIES OF PROVEN COLLABORATION AND VISIBILITY

The City Manager serves at the center of many conversations—between the City Council and staff, between residents and local government, and often between differing viewpoints within the community itself. For this reason, many communities look for a City Manager who can serve as a “bridge builder,” someone capable of fostering collaboration and guiding constructive dialogue.  Strong collaboration helps ensure that difficult decisions are approached with respect, transparency, and an understanding of multiple perspectives. In communities where residents care deeply about the direction of their city, the ability to listen carefully, communicate clearly, and help people work toward shared solutions becomes an essential leadership skill.  Equally important is visibility within the community. In towns like Harbor Springs, residents often value leaders who are present, approachable, and engaged in the life of the community. A City Manager who maintains strong connections with residents, local organizations, and regional partners can help strengthen trust in local government while also ensuring that community concerns are heard and understood.

QUESTIONS 

  • Can you provide a specific example where you successfully brought together diverse groups—whether internally (staff, council members) or externally (community groups or regional partners)—to achieve a common goal? How did you address differing opinions or conflicting interests to move the collaboration forward?
  • How would you encourage ongoing collaboration in Harbor Springs, particularly when the community faces complex or contentious issues?
  • The community expects its City Manager to be visible and engaged. How would you approach connecting with residents, attending community events, and demonstrating your commitment to Harbor Springs in your day-to-day role?
  • How would you balance the demands of administrative responsibilities with the importance of remaining visible and accessible within the community?

BUDGET CONCERNS

Harbor Springs, like many communities, is facing growing budget pressures, particularly as the cost of capital projects and infrastructure maintenance continues to rise. Careful prioritization and long-term planning will be essential in determining how limited public resources are allocated.

QUESTIONS 

  • Harbor Springs is facing growing budget pressures, particularly with the rising cost of capital projects and infrastructure needs. How do you approach setting priorities and making difficult spending decisions when a city’s financial model cannot support every proposed project?
  • In recent years, many residents have expressed interest in refocusing municipal spending toward core responsibilities such as infrastructure maintenance, electric system upgrades, and tree safety near power lines. How important is it for City Council and city administration to understand the level of community support when considering shifts in budget priorities?
  • Can you share an example from your experience where you had to say “no” to a project or initiative because it did not align with the city’s financial realities or long-term priorities?
  • Harbor Springs has a Downtown Development Authority that uses Tax Increment Financing (TIF) and sometimes General Fund resources for downtown and tourism-related initiatives. How do you view the balance between investing in visitor-oriented amenities and ensuring adequate funding for essential services such as infrastructure maintenance and storm safety?
  • Some residents have raised questions about how taxpayer General Fund dollars are allocated, particularly when new amenities create ongoing maintenance costs in parks or public spaces. How would you approach evaluating those trade-offs and ensuring a balanced allocation of resources?
  • The city also relies in part on donor contributions for park improvements, with a portion of those funds designated for ongoing maintenance. How would you evaluate whether that model is working effectively, and how would you ensure parks are maintained while also encouraging responsible use of public green spaces?
  • There has also been discussion about the operational costs associated with the Downtown Development Authority. How do you evaluate organizational overhead and ensure that administrative spending remains appropriate while still supporting staff and delivering essential services effectively?

WE HOPE THESE QUESTIONS WILL HELP HARBOR SPRINGS LOOK TO CHOOSING THE NEXT CITY MANAGER

As Harbor Springs considers candidates for this position, or chooses to wait for new candidates to be selected,  the discussion should focus on the skills and experience most important for managing the city’s unique responsibilities. When we look for things like good communicaitons skills, a good hiring process asks for demonstrated performance.